Journal — Ceremonies, Part 3/5
Incense Ceremonies: North America
Field notes · December 10, 2021
The third part of the series turns to a practice that is at once one of the world’s best known and most frequently misunderstood: the smudging traditions of Native America.

White sage (Salvia apiana) in Joshua Tree National Park — Photo: Joshua Tree National Park, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons
Few incense rituals have become as popular outside their originating context as ‘smudging’ with white sage (Salvia apiana), a plant that grows only in the dry coastal regions of Southern California and Baja California. In numerous Indigenous traditions of North America — among them the Chumash, the Lakota, and many Californian peoples, though by no means all in the same form — burning sage serves to clear a person, a space, or an object of negative energy, often embedded in prayers, songs, or larger ceremonial contexts.
Alongside sage, sweetgrass (Hierochloe odorata) plays a central role, usually braided into long plaits and often burned only after the sage — symbolically, first driving out the negative, then inviting in the positive, the sweet. Cedar, in turn, especially among the Anishinaabe and many Plains peoples, is regarded as a protective plant, often burned in connection with drum ceremonies or the entering of sacred spaces. Together with tobacco, these three plants form the so-called ‘four sacred plants’ as understood in many, though not all, North American traditions.
What matters here is this: there is no single, unified ‘Indigenous incense ritual’. The more than five hundred federally recognized tribes in the United States alone — from the coastal peoples of California to the Haudenosaunee in the northeast — maintain distinct, often very different spiritual practices, which moreover rarely stand alone but are embedded in larger ceremonial, communal, and often healing contexts that frequently remain hidden from an outside view.
The global popularity of ‘smudging’ — found today in countless wellness contexts, yoga studios and esoteric shops worldwide, usually detached from any religious or cultural framework — has led in recent years to a growing, more nuanced debate. What is criticized is rarely the practice of burning incense as such, which nearly every culture on earth has found its own form of, but two quite specific things: the use of particular, protected terms and sacred objects outside their ritual context, and a commercial overharvesting of Salvia apiana, which is now visibly declining within its limited natural range.
Botanically, white sage is not a cultivated plant in any straightforward sense — it grows wild, slowly, on hard-to-reach slopes, and can hardly be farmed sustainably at scale. The international boom has put pressure on exactly the plant that, in its original use, was always harvested in small, deliberate quantities.
Against this backdrop, a project like Incense of Music 52, which in November 2021 worked explicitly with white sage, carries a particular responsibility rather than a mere choice of material: an incense material with such a specific cultural history is hard to treat as pure aroma, detached from the question of where it comes from and who first understood it as sacred.
It is also worth noting that practices like these were, for a long time, by no means self-evidently protected under US law: only the American Indian Religious Freedom Act of 1978 made clear that traditional spiritual practices — including access to sacred sites and materials — enjoy constitutional protection, after they had been actively suppressed for much of the nineteenth and twentieth centuries by state assimilation policy, including at the so-called boarding schools, where Indigenous religious ceremonies remained forbidden for decades.
Other North American traditions remain far less known internationally, though they are equally old — the burning of copal-like resins among Mesoamerican-influenced communities in the present-day American Southwest, for instance, or the specific tobacco ceremonies of the Haudenosaunee, in which tobacco is not smoked but burned, so that prayers may literally ‘rise’. They are a reminder that ‘North American incense ceremony’ is a collective term for a diversity that resists reduction to a single image — sage smoke over an abalone shell — however widespread that image has since become.

Deutsch